Family Forum / Parenting / Adoption / May 2006

Judge Strikes Down Okla. Gay Adoption Law

By TIM TALLEY
Associated Press Writer

May 20, 2006, 7:21 AM EDT

OKLAHOMA CITY -- A federal judge struck down a 2-year-old law that prohibits
Oklahoma from recognizing adoptions by same-sex couples from other states and
countries.

U.S. District Judge Robin Cauthron ruled Friday the measure violated due process
rights under the U.S. Constitution because it attempted to break up families
without considering the parents' fitness or the children's best interests.

Gay-rights organization Lambda Legal had challenged the law on behalf of three
same-sex couples.

"Gay and lesbian parents in Oklahoma can now breathe a collective sigh of relief
because their relationships with their children are no longer threatened by the
state of Oklahoma," said Ken Upton, an attorney in Lambda Legal's Dallas office.

One of the plaintiffs, Heather Finstuen, said the ruling will allow her and
partner Anne Magro to focus on being parents to their 7-year-old twin girls
rather than worrying about the adoption law.

"This is really good news for our family," she said. "It's a huge relief."

The couple said the law endangered the legal relationship established by a New
Jersey court between Finstuen and her adopted daughters. The girls were born to
Magro.

The ruling was attacked by supporters of the law, which was passed by the
Legislature with bipartisan support in 2004.

"It's another case of an activist court trying to legislate from the bench,"
said Republican Rep. Thad Balkman. "It's unfortunate that a single judge is
trying to rewrite the law."

Copyright 2006 Associated Press Inc.,
______________________________________
Reprinted for educational purposes only.