> >>>>>> "christy murphy" <wlxogaahrjtt@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:f2414eb2-d551-4b1c-8d7e-f9d249e47372@d10g2000pra.googlegroups.com...
> >>>>>>> The telephone ring; it's a call from your child's teacher. The
> > teacher
[quoted text clipped - 48 lines]
> See below. Home schooling *as a whole* is much better at educating
> children.
Stats please.
I fully agree that there are exceptions and not everyone is fit
> to do so. As a group they do much better than public schooled children.
> Just as there are a few exceptional public school teachers there are a few
> unfit home school teachers. However, as a whole, the public school system
> in the US is fatally flawed. Why do you think so many public school
> teachers send their own children to private schools?
Well just to balance your sterotype, in my neck of the woods I don't know
too many that do.
I wish I sent my
> children to private school.
I thought home schooling was your gold standard?
It would have been a cheap investment in their
> lives and would have eliminated many of their problems.
Isn't it a parent's job to teach their child how to deal with problems?
In a private
> school a student who attacks another student with scissors would have been
> appropriately dealt with. In public school the principal just wrote it
> off.
So you think that because that happened to you that that happens across the
board in public schools?
Honestly I should have pressed formal assault charges against the
> boy. My bad.
Yep.
Kathy 1
Mike Dobony - 15 Oct 2008 14:56 GMT
>>>>>>>> "christy murphy" <wlxogaahrjtt@yahoo.com> wrote in message
>>>
[quoted text clipped - 63 lines]
>
> Stats please.
http://www.hslda.org/docs/nche/000000/00000017.asp
> I fully agree that there are exceptions and not everyone is fit
>> to do so. As a group they do much better than public schooled children.
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> Well just to balance your sterotype, in my neck of the woods I don't know
> too many that do.
It is more than a sterotype. A sterotype is a generalized perception based
upon first impressions. The fact is that homeschoolers as a whole do much
better socially, academically, and in the workplace has been documented for
years. It is much more than a first impression.
> I wish I sent my
>> children to private school.
>
> I thought home schooling was your gold standard?
No, many parents are not fit to homeschool. Private schools are much
better. Private schools also do a much better job of dealing with bullies.
Better to get rid of one bully than to loose 5 or 6 students due to the
bully.
> It would have been a cheap investment in their
>> lives and would have eliminated many of their problems.
>
> Isn't it a parent's job to teach their child how to deal with problems?
teach and protect and give them the best possible. The fact is the US
public school system is fatally flawed. Teachers are not allowed to do
what is necessary to maintain discipline.
Then again, we could teach the victims martial arts to be able to defend
themselves. But then we also have zero-tolerance schools which punish the
victim for defending themselves, resulting in few disclosures of bullies, a
very real problem in public schools.
The proper method of dealing with bullies is reporting it to authorities.
Public school administrators, as a whole, are restricted from dealing with
bullies. It is not a child's duty to beat the bully to a pulp, the only
effective method of dealing with them if an administrator refuses to get
rid of the bully. If the administration will remove them (not just
suspended for a day or two, but expelled) then we have a totally different
and positive situation. By law we can not kick them out until age 16.
Where do they go? Most private schools will not deal with them. Only a
few military type schools have the resources to deal with bullies and very
few can afford to send their children there and the government will not pay
to send them there. Therefore the school administrator's hands are tied.
They give the bully a day or two off of school, much to the delight of the
bully.
> In a private
>> school a student who attacks another student with scissors would have been
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> So you think that because that happened to you that that happens across the
> board in public schools?
It didn't just happen to me. It was part of the culture of educators who
are not allowed by law to do what is necessary to maintain control in the
classroom and to hold back students who are not ready for the next grade.
I know many a parent who has the same complaints.
http://www.jaredstory.com/been_harassed.html
http://nces.ed.gov/programs/crimeindicators/crimeindicators2005/Indicators.asp?P
ubPageNumber=12
http://nces.ed.gov/programs/crimeindicators/crimeindicators2005/Indicators.asp?P
ubPageNumber=4
http://www.conservapedia.com/Public_school
> Honestly I should have pressed formal assault charges against the
>> boy. My bad.
>
> Yep.
>
> Kathy 1