Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
Parenting
ParentingMothersSingle ParentsStep ParentsAdoptionTwinsSpankingChildren's Health
Pregnancy
PregnancyBreastfeeding
Marriage
MarriageDivorce
FamilyKB.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

Family Forum / Parenting / Children's Health / March 2006



Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Breastfeeding for life?

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Hairchair - 09 Mar 2006 01:11 GMT
Someone get Chuck Lysaght on the horn!

http://www.newsandstar.co.uk/news/viewarticle.aspx?id=328277&imageindex=1

Why I still breastfeed my eight-year-old girl

Published on 04/02/2006

by Phil Coleman

A PENRITH mum has appeared on national TV to explain why she is still
breastfeeding her daughter who is nearly eight - and why she gave her
older daughter breast milk as a ninth birthday present.

Veronika Robinson appeared on the Channel 4 programme Extraordinary
Breastfeeding as a passionate advocate of allowing children to decided
when they give up breast milk.

Mrs Robinson, a former journalist, her husband Paul, and their
children, Bethany and Elizah, are all fans of organic food.

Elizah is approaching her eighth birthday and is not happy at the
prospect of giving up her daily feed. "I don't want to be weaned. I
want to breastfeed for ever," she said.

In the Channel 4 programme, broadcast on Wednesday, Mrs Robinson, 38,
spoke frankly about her decision to defy convention.

She was one of several families interviewed after the World Health
Organisation recommended that children should be breastfed until they
are aged two. All share the belief that children should never be
forcibly weaned.

While many people in the UK consider her decision odd, other cultures
do not take such a dim view of prolonged breast feeding.

In an interview before the TV programme, 38-year-old Veronika described
her reaction when Bethany asked for breast milk for her ninth birthday.
"I was delighted, if a little taken aback,' she said.

"I'd stopped breastfeeding Bethany when she was five - though I was
continuing to feed her younger sister, Elizah - but obviously she
clearly remembered what a wonderful feeling it had been. It was the
best thing she could imagine and, presented like that, it seemed like a
great idea."

Veronika, who edits an alternative-parenting magazine called The Mother
continued: "My girls were brought up to think it was completely
normal to ask for a breast in a shop," she says. "That's bad
enough when they are toddlers, but when they are big girls, people get
freaked out by it.

"I try to be discreet, but we have had some odd looks. People tend to
be disgusted and disbelieving."

"I can't believe any mother wouldn't love to hold onto that
wonderful feeling you get when you are nursing your own child."

Despite the Breast Is Best campaign, designed to highlight the benefits
of breastfeeding to new born babies, only 68 per cent of mums routinely
breastfeed. Of those around 80 per cent give up after just six months.
Jamie Clark - 09 Mar 2006 05:30 GMT
> Someone get Chuck Lysaght on the horn!
>
> http://www.newsandstar.co.uk/news/viewarticle.aspx?id=328277&imageindex=1
>
> Why I still breastfeed my eight-year-old girl

SNIP

Uhm...Well, they do look healthy.
Signature


Jamie
Earth Angels:
Taylor Marlys, 1/3/03
Addison Grace, 9/30/04

Check out the family! -- www.MyFamily.com, User ID:  Clarkguest1,
Password: Guest Become a member for free - go to Add Member to set up
your own User ID and Password

Twittering One - 09 Mar 2006 05:40 GMT
A bit overweight for kids.
justwaxing@yahoo.com.au - 09 Mar 2006 08:30 GMT
> Someone get Chuck Lysaght on the horn!
>
[quoted text clipped - 57 lines]
> of breastfeeding to new born babies, only 68 per cent of mums routinely
> breastfeed. Of those around 80 per cent give up after just six months.

I can't quite put my finger on why I feel such revulsion towards
mothers who breastfeed for so long. I think it's because they gain some
sort of sexual pleasure from having the child at their breast. It is
not the role of the child to give a mother that "wonderful feeling" via
breastfeeding I think these women are lacking something in their lives.
A child asking for breast milk for their 9th birthday is clearly not a
normal thing to do. However, I fully support the right of women to
breastfeed children in public - just not 8 and 9 year olds!
Elfanie - 09 Mar 2006 18:09 GMT
>I can't quite put my finger on why I feel such revulsion towards
>mothers who breastfeed for so long.

wow....revulsion is quite a strong word.

> I think it's because they gain some
>sort of sexual pleasure from having the child at their breast. It is
>not the role of the child to give a mother that "wonderful feeling" via
>breastfeeding

*heavy sigh*
Have you never nursed a baby/child??  goodness gracious why does it
always seem to come back to a sexual thing for people who have never
done it??
and why is a "wonderful feeling" something sexual to you?  I find THAT
repulsive...that your mind goes to sex.  I have wonderful feelings
whenever I nurse any of my children.....it's called love.  Love to me
is a wonderful feeling...

and love, to me, is not sexual.

>I think these women are lacking something in their lives.

Why do you think this?
And what do you think is lacking, in your opinion?

>A child asking for breast milk for their 9th birthday is clearly not a
>normal thing to do.

It actually can be....depending on the circumstances.  When I gave
birth to my third child...my oldest, who was 7 at the time, asked what
breastmilk tasted like.  I expressed some and he drank it...didn't
like it...and we moved on.
That's actually VERY VERY common.

>However, I fully support the right of women to
>breastfeed children in public - just not 8 and 9 year olds!

What is the age limit at which a woman should no longer be able to
nurse her child?

Stephanie Soderblom CLD CCCE CD(DONA) CBC
Mommy to Mikael 5/9/95 - Kerstyn 8/6/99 - Kevin 8/30/02
and Megan 5/16/05
Birth Minister/Doula/CBE/Pregnancy-Birth Photography
Mesa, AZ
http://www.birthdiaries.com
VISIT OUR NEW ONLINE STORE!
xkatx - 09 Mar 2006 19:06 GMT
>>I can't quite put my finger on why I feel such revulsion towards
>>mothers who breastfeed for so long.
>
> wow....revulsion is quite a strong word.

I find it just odd, in some way, but I would never think to use revulsion.
It's probably based on the norm around here.

>> I think it's because they gain some
>>sort of sexual pleasure from having the child at their breast. It is
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> always seem to come back to a sexual thing for people who have never
> done it??

I've nursed all my children.  I don't think of nursing at all in a sexual
way.

> and why is a "wonderful feeling" something sexual to you?  I find THAT
> repulsive...that your mind goes to sex.  I have wonderful feelings
> whenever I nurse any of my children.....it's called love.  Love to me
> is a wonderful feeling...

I agree.  I have always found nursing to be MY bond with my child.
Something that only I have ever done with my children that no one else ever
has.  Anyone - grandparents, dad, aunts, uncles, cousins, siblings, friends,
whatever, can change baby's diaper, give baths, whatever, but no one else
was ever able to nurse my babies.  It's definitely love, and a time that a
mother can have with her child that no one can really take away or take over
on.

> and love, to me, is not sexual.
>
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
> What is the age limit at which a woman should no longer be able to
> nurse her child?

For me, yes, I probably would wonder why on earth someone is nursing a child
of that age.  I wouldn't sit and dwell on it, and my life would go on just
the same.  I think, the way it is for me, is that I do believe that nursing
is a natural and normal thing to do.  I nursed mine, and I didn't have a
whole lot of support, other than my own mother.  The females in my family
weren't very supportive, and the males would have nothing but
discouragement, other than my dad who didn't really care either way.  He was
there when my mother nurse my brothers and I, and he was alright if I sat
down and nursed mine, and all I did was toss a receiving blanket over me and
baby.  Partly since I didn't think my dad or anyone else really cared to
actually watch, it made it more comfortable for everyone else - myself
included - and all my children had a thing with blankets where they'd fall
right asleep when they had a receiving blanket the covered their faces.
Kind of like a comfort thing.
I find nursing completely normal, healthy, fine, I'm totally good with it,
and I don't mind carrying on any type of conversation or discussion with
someone while I nurse or while they do.  I also think about every mamal and
how mamals, humans included, nurse their young.  I also think about how
mamals eventually wean or are weaned from their mother and are expected to
be on their own.  Humans are the only mamals that tend to keep their young
under their wing for so long.  When you think about something like a cat,
and for an easy number, let's say cats live 15 years.  A human let's say
lives 75 years - for another easy number.  That's 5 times longer that people
live when compared to a cat.  A kitten is normally weaned by about 6-8
weeks, sometimes longer, sometimes shorter.  By around those 6-8 weeks of
age, a kitten is usually ready to venture out on their own and have a new
family or would be alright without needing its mother so much.  People
normally aren't ready to be on their own until they're done school, have a
job, whatever, and that's probably anywhere around 20 or so years of age,
and again, sometimes earlier, sometimes longer.
So after all this rambling that makes very little sense (as I read it over
again!) all I'm trying to say is that although nursing is natural, it's also
natural to wean.  When that should be done does depend on what you're
talking about - cats, dogs, monkeys, mice, whatever.  Humans, we tend to be
at a fairly higher level than a cat, but as human beings - animals - it's
still a natural thing to wean your children, and for me, it was just before
the time that mine could lift my shirt up and help themselves, but again,
although I would find it definitely strange, in my own personal opinion, my
life would go on, I wouldn't be permanantely damaged, and maybe it would
strike me as odd and bothersome, but the great thing is... If I don't like
something, agree with something, want to do or see something, I can just as
easily turn around and walk away and go about my day as normal, just as any
other person, no matter what their choices and beliefs may be!
Just my 2¢, backed up with why!

> Stephanie Soderblom CLD CCCE CD(DONA) CBC
> Mommy to Mikael 5/9/95 - Kerstyn 8/6/99 - Kevin 8/30/02
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> http://www.birthdiaries.com
> VISIT OUR NEW ONLINE STORE!
Dennis M. Hammes - 09 Mar 2006 18:29 GMT
> Someone get Chuck Lysaght on the horn!

And here's to chew Mrs. Robinson!

> http://www.newsandstar.co.uk/news/viewarticle.aspx?id=328277&imageindex=1
>
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> Mrs Robinson, a former journalist, her husband Paul, and their
> children, Bethany and Elizah, are all fans of organic food.

Signature

-------(m+
  ~/:o)_|
/Addo, ergo sum/.
http://scrawlmark.org

admin@pmbbay.com - 09 Mar 2006 22:59 GMT
Quite an interesting article. Feel free to view our Disney Princess
4 piece Toddler Bedding Sets or browse all of our Character bed bedding
sets.

Now available in the US, UK and Australia: Our online address is
www.pmbbay.com or http://www.pmbbay.com

Feel free to email us anytime if you need assistance.

PMBBAY
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2010 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.