Realistic expectations from a marriage
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Aaron Morgan - 20 Apr 2006 09:23 GMT Having been together with my GF a couple of years she thinks it's about time to get married or move on and I'm utterly confused about what I should do. Having been single for many years, and in my late thirties a lot of things come into mind. I'm not getting any younger, I don't want to be alone for the rest of my life, and what hopes do I have of meeting THE one, but how do I know if I should go for this or not? I'm not head over heels in love. Actually I don't even know if I'm in love, or if fear just prevents me from being in love, or if she ain't the right girl for me. I have a feeling that when things get serious I get scared and back off, which is what I'm probably doing now. How do I know if she's the one? I always had this picture in my head of meeting Ms. Perfect, everything would match, everything would be great, but this isn't. What do I do? I guess I'm asking for some advice and thoughts on the matter.
Regards, Aaron
Stephanie - 20 Apr 2006 13:31 GMT > Having been together with my GF a couple of years she thinks it's about > time to get married or move on and I'm utterly confused about what I [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > > Regards, Aaron My motto is, when in doubt, don't get married.
Rog' - 20 Apr 2006 13:48 GMT > Having been together with my GF a couple of years she thinks > it's about time to get married or move on and I'm utterly confused [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > would be great, but this isn't. What do I do? I guess I'm asking > for some advice and thoughts on the matter. The idea that one day, you will meet your true love, fall madly and hopelessly in love, marry and live happily ever after, is a construct of fairy-tales and Walt Disney. It happens, but is a stupid way of choosing a mate for life, 'cuz often you come to find out that you did not know them well enuff and they were not the person you has idolized. In reality, its nuch better to choose to love a person as an informed and conscious decision, knowing who they are.
Cold feet is not unusual, but I can tell you thst there is life after marriage. Its not like you disappear. The bottom-line is, are you okay with losing her and moving on, or do you want to make a life-time commitment? =R=
rj - 20 Apr 2006 15:59 GMT > > Having been together with my GF a couple of years she thinks > > it's about time to get married or move on She's probably right. And after "a couple of years", who could blame her?
> > and I'm utterly confused > > about what I should do. <snip> [quoted text clipped - 15 lines] > okay with losing her and moving on, or do you want to make a > life-time commitment? =R= What Rog' said.
rj
_mL_ - 20 Apr 2006 16:41 GMT >Having been together with my GF a couple of years she thinks it's about >time to get married or move on and I'm utterly confused about what I [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > >Regards, Aaron If you have doubts, then don't get married. Talk with her about it openly.
She has the right to decide if she wants to invest more of her time and emotion into a relationship that may not be going the direction she wants for the future. And you have the right not to feel pressured into making a commitment that you're uncomfortable with.
If you're still having "hopes of meeting THE one" while you're *in* a relationship, then i would guess that this person isn't "the one"...
Emma Anne - 20 Apr 2006 18:00 GMT > Having been together with my GF a couple of years she thinks it's about > time to get married or move on and I'm utterly confused about what I [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > would match, everything would be great, but this isn't. What do I do? I > guess I'm asking for some advice and thoughts on the matter. Don't get married. Marrying someone you don't love is a recipe for disaster. Bennthere, done that, got the divorce.
Aaron Morgan - 20 Apr 2006 22:57 GMT Thanks for all your replies. All of what you say sounds reasonable, and it's basically the things I've thought myself. But I'm wondering if fear has something to do with it. I know that I have a lot of fear from way back, which affects a lot of decisions and things I do -especially big decisions. This is what confuses me: are my doubts legit, or are they a part of my fear. To me, getting married sounds like a scary thing. Something very definite and unchangeable (I liked what Rog' said about not disappearing and life goes on after marriage) and it's easy to say "Nope, I'm backing out", which is something I could do. But what's the alternative? I've been alone and lonely for such a long time that I don't want to go back to that again. I do like to have her around, but I don't feel madly, passionately in love. What is "being in love" anyway? Does the feeling disappear as you get older? I don't seem to feel much of anything these days. I notice that I do look at other girls a lot. It's not that she's not good looking, because she is, but not in the bombshell kinda way. But I have noticed one thing: the girls I like are in their twenties, so no wonder many of them look amazing! So what does all of this mean? I guess I'm trying to figure out a failsafe way of checking if I should go ahead or not, seeing that I don't really know what I feel or want out of life.
Doug Anderson - 20 Apr 2006 23:19 GMT > Thanks for all your replies. > All of what you say sounds reasonable, and it's basically the things [quoted text clipped - 19 lines] > go ahead or not, seeing that I don't really know what I feel or want > out of life. OK. Well, first: being in love doesn't mean (at least for lots of us) that you stop noticing other attractive women.
I can tell you something about what it means for me, but these things aren't in a very good order, and I have no idea how well they reflect other people's experiences of being in love:
-I enjoy spending time with my wife. I look forward to being with her when I'm not with her, I enjoy snuggling up to her in bed while we're sleeping, I want to spend vacations with her, etc. -I want to know what she thinks about things. I want her perspective on our friends and children. On movies we see together, on what she likes and what she doesn't like. -I want her to be happy and contented. Perhaps for completely selfish reasons - it is more fun for _me_ to be with her when she's happy, so it makes me happy too. But at the same time, I get enjoyment out of doing things which I know will please her.
These are all apart from (though perhaps not unrelated to) the strong physical attraction I still experience for her.
They are also apart from the similarities of experiences (we've been married a long time) which lead to feelings of intimacy between us, even in a crowd.
So, my question to you is: are these things you can imagine feeling for your girlfriend, and imagine wanting to build on and reinforce over the long-term?
My perspective would be that if the answer to that question is yes, then marriage might make sense, if the answer to it is no, then you won't be able to stay happily married. Of course some people would rather be unhappily married than alone (I'm not like this, but I can believe that some others are), and this is another thing to consider.
Tai - 20 Apr 2006 23:38 GMT >> Thanks for all your replies. >> All of what you say sounds reasonable, and it's basically the things [quoted text clipped - 45 lines] > married a long time) which lead to feelings of intimacy between us, > even in a crowd. Oh good, this saves me writing out my list when I really shouldn't spare the time to go online today at all!
Just to add a little more - loving my husband means I look forward to seeing him again when he's not around and I experience a welling of happiness and a frisson of pleasure when I set eyes on him again. I also experience a strong feeling of tenderness for him when he's ill or unhappy and I naturally turn to him for comfort, too. He's my best friend.
> So, my question to you is: are these things you can imagine feeling > for your girlfriend, and imagine wanting to build on and reinforce [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > rather be unhappily married than alone (I'm not like this, but I can > believe that some others are), and this is another thing to consider. Yep.
Aaron, both Doug and I have been married to our respective spouses for over 20 years. I can't speak for him but I would be horrified to know the man I wished to spend the rest of my life with had such tepid feelings for me. Really, if you actually like this woman don't 'settle' for her! It would be very cruel.
Tai
> Inviato da X-Privat.Org - Registrazione gratuita > http://www.x-privat.org/join.php Kitty - 21 Apr 2006 01:59 GMT > > Thanks for all your replies. > > All of what you say sounds reasonable, and it's basically the things [quoted text clipped - 30 lines] > her when I'm not with her, I enjoy snuggling up to her in bed while > we're sleeping, I want to spend vacations with her, etc. Awww, that's so sweet :D and for Aaron, I'd like to point out that speaks of good physical and a bit of emotional compatibility
> -I want to know what she thinks about things. I want her perspective > on our friends and children. On movies we see together, on what she > likes and what she doesn't like. Intellectual compatibility
> -I want her to be happy and contented. Perhaps for completely > selfish reasons - it is more fun for _me_ to be with her when she's > happy, so it makes me happy too. But at the same time, I get > enjoyment out of doing things which I know will please her. More emphasis on emotional compatibility! :)
> These are all apart from (though perhaps not unrelated to) the strong > physical attraction I still experience for her. [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > rather be unhappily married than alone (I'm not like this, but I can > believe that some others are), and this is another thing to consider. This concept of rather being unhappily married then being alone takes some work and grief and lonely times to overcome, but I can guarantee that (at least for me) once I overcame it the grass got a lot greener on that side. I strongly recommend overcoming that. Lot of good things happen when we do.
Kitty - 21 Apr 2006 01:54 GMT > Thanks for all your replies. > All of what you say sounds reasonable, and it's basically the things [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > things I do -especially big decisions. This is what confuses me: are my > doubts legit, or are they a part of my fear. You'll have to think about those one at the time, and decide if they're realistic and objective, or if you're reacting to your fears. Ask yourself, am I thinking most likely scenario - which is most often near the middle of the road, or am I fearing the worst case scenario - which doesn't happen all that often. Also, look at whether your fears are based on something that you actually see happening, or if they're a product of your mind, like, statistics say "a" so I'm afraid she will do "a" even if knowing her "a" is just not her style.
> To me, getting married sounds like a scary thing. Something very > definite and unchangeable (I liked what Rog' said about not > disappearing and life goes on after marriage) and it's easy to say > "Nope, I'm backing out", which is something I could do. You have to decide that you are willing to give it your best shot. Even when things don't work out, you can get a lot of satisfaction in knowing you tried your best. Some things in life we just can't control or predict, we can just deal with them as they come.
> But what's the alternative? I've been alone and lonely for such a long > time that I don't want to go back to that again. That's *alone* not a very good reason to hang around.
> I do like to have her > around, but I don't feel madly, passionately in love. What is "being in > love" anyway? > Does the feeling disappear as you get older? It can come and go, passion does subside.
> I don't seem > to feel much of anything these days. That might be a part of what's going on with you. When I find myself in a spot like that, I like to go see a shrink to talk things over. I usually tell him, I need to talk a few things over, something bothers me, and I can't figure it out, or I cant put my finger on it, or I'm unsure what to do. Shrinks are usually really good in asking questions and giving you food for thought, sort of lead you to figure out what's up with you. It dowsn't mean something is wrong, it's more like regular maintenance, like a 30,000 K service on a car.
> I notice that I do look at other girls a lot. Mos men do, that's just a part of being a male.
> It's not that she's not > good looking, because she is, but not in the bombshell kinda way. But I > have noticed one thing: the girls I like are in their twenties, so no > wonder many of them look amazing! So what does all of this mean? That you have a sex drive (which is normal), and you're still pretty focused on it (lot of men are, so you're pretty normal in that aspect too), and not so focused on your feelings and other aspects of your personality. It may not be a bad thing for you to spend some time on your own. Those are the times when most personal growth occures. I think your emotional and spiritual side needs little more growth and learning before you're ready for marriage.
> I guess I'm trying to figure out a failsafe way of checking if I should > go ahead or not, seeing that I don't really know what I feel or want > out of life. There's no failsafe things in life, but you do have to at least have an inkling of a few things you want out of life. You learn that by spending some more time on your own, getting to know yourself. Times when one feels lonely might just be the best times for personal and emotional growth. Having another person around often makes it too easy to focus on them, and not spend enough time with ourselves to grow and learn who we are and what we want.
Emma Anne - 21 Apr 2006 18:14 GMT > What is "being in > love" anyway? Does the feeling disappear as you get older? I don't seem > to feel much of anything these days. I am going to reiterate: don't marry someone you don't love, and it really doesn't sound like you love your girlfriend. I asked "what is love anyway?" when I was married to my ex. I don't ask it now. I *know* I love my H.
I *do* think it is OK to get married if you have doubts *about marriage.* I did. I am not a person who is sure of things or can't see alternatives or ways things could go wrong. But I don't think it is OK to get married of you have doubts about whether you want *this person*.
Grace - 21 Apr 2006 18:55 GMT > I guess I'm trying to figure out a failsafe way of checking if I should > go ahead or not, seeing that I don't really know what I feel or want > out of life. Aaron:
Do this woman a favor and cut here loose. She deserves to find happiness with a man who knows that he loves her and knows that he wants to spend the rest of his life with her.
and do yourself a favor....don't mary her because she will enventually figure out how you really feel, be mad as hell and this will turn into a very, very ugly divorce.
Grace
Kitty - 21 Apr 2006 01:34 GMT > Having been together with my GF a couple of years she thinks it's about > time to get married or move on and I'm utterly confused about what I [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > my life, and what hopes do I have of meeting THE one, but how do I know > if I should go for this or not? If you don't know who or what you want, you'll never find it. More realistic approach would be to learn to want what you can have.
> I'm not head over heels in love. Actually I don't even know if I'm in > love, or if fear just prevents me from being in love, or if she ain't > the right girl for me. I have a feeling that when things get serious I > get scared and back off, which is what I'm probably doing now. How do I > know if she's the one? Go see a professional (usually a psychologist), an appointment or two, they're usually really good as someone to talk these kinds of things over. They'll usually ask you questions that will make you think...
> I always had this picture in my head of meeting Ms. Perfect, everything > would match, everything would be great, but this isn't. What do I do? Give up the fairytales.
> guess I'm asking for some advice and thoughts on the matter. > > Regards, Aaron Learn what's realistic. Hint, perfection is not reality. If you;re waiting for perfect, you'll die alone and jaded.
Learn more about yourself and what YOU want and what suits you and what YOU WANT ( out of life and in a way of compatibility with someone else)
If you're not sure she's the one, don't lead you GF on. Don't continue to date someone if after a few months you don't start feeling like she *might* be the one, and you want to keep seeing her to see if things will move in the right direction.
Sushi Fish - 24 Apr 2006 04:13 GMT If you are in doubt, listen to your inner voice. You don't want to marry because you are afraid of being alone. Marriage is more than a moment of hot passions nor flattery; they are little comforts and pleasures that keep you and your partner going. She gave you the ultimatum, take it at face values. When you feel sure, you know it. Marriage is a long path, easy or not, depends on your passion and will.
Sushi Fish - 24 Apr 2006 04:19 GMT ... and the commitment of your partner, I might add
Dr. Di - 24 Apr 2006 13:08 GMT > Having been together with my GF a couple of years she thinks it's about > time to get married or move on and I'm utterly confused about what I [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > > Regards, Aaron Personally I think you have an intelligent and determined girlfriend.. She's made a couple years investment in you and finally decided that it's time to make the commitment, or move on.. Good for her!
Marriage isn't so scary for most emotionally healthy people.. You seem to think that you may have an unconscious fear of love and commitment.. Please consider NPD (narcissistic personality disorder) as a possible cause..
You say you may not love her, and indeed you may not, but then why are you with her? Is she aware of your doubts, or are you frightened she'll leave you if you're honest concerning your possible lack of love for her?
Please don't ruin her life if you're on some kind of self destructive binge.. Be honest with her at the very least.. Most women tend to actually believe "I love you" means just what it says, and if you don't mean it, then let her go to find a real and healthy love... Emotional well being, which is necessary for her happiness, is a terrible thing to waste...
Diana
samvaknin - 27 Apr 2006 15:47 GMT Hi,
Only a qualified mental health diagnostician can determine whether someone suffers from Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) and this, following lengthy tests and personal interviews.
You may find these of added interest:
http://malignantselflove.tripod.com/npdglance.html
http://malignantselflove.tripod.com/intimacyabuse.html
http://malignantselflove.tripod.com/abuse14.html
http://malignantselflove.tripod.com/journal60.html
http://malignantselflove.tripod.com/journal69.html
http://malignantselflove.tripod.com/faq79.html
http://malignantselflove.tripod.com/faq6.html
http://malignantselflove.tripod.com/faq66.html
Take care.
Sam
> > Having been together with my GF a couple of years she thinks it's about > > time to get married or move on and I'm utterly confused about what I [quoted text clipped - 35 lines] > > Diana Dr. Di - 28 Apr 2006 01:50 GMT > Hi, > [quoted text clipped - 23 lines] > > Sam Thank you for the advice and information Sam..
I am of the belief that if a tire goes "thump, thump, thump", it likely is going flat.. Expert advice may be necessary to diagnose NPD, but the symptoms are usually suggestive to the aware non professional as well.. I'm a research scientist, and I find the methods of discovery in my field useful to the study of my husband's narcissistic behavior..
My life is similar to living with a circus clown, and the rest of the circus as well :)
Tell me Sam, is it sporadically possible for narcissists to "eliminate" their spouse, who perhaps stopped playing their games?
You have a great deal to teach us concerning NPD, and a great responsibility to do so.. Perhaps you don't care, but I'd like to think that you do!
Diana
samvaknin - 01 May 2006 11:31 GMT Hi, Diana,
There are degrees of narcissism - from the healthy to the extremely pathological (malignant). pathological narcissism, unlike a flat tyre, is a complex psychological construct.
Read this:
http://malignantselflove.tripod.com/1.html
Here is the first and foremost lesson I have to teach:
Only a qualified mental health diagnostician can determine whether someone suffers from Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) and this, following lengthy tests and personal interviews.
Regarding murder and crime:
NPD (Narcissistic Personality Disorder) and AsPD (Antisocial Personality Disorder)
http://personalitydisorders.suite101.com/article.cfm/narcissistpsychopath
http://www.narcissistic-abuse.com/faq15.html
http://www.narcissistic-abuse.com/faq82.html
http://malignantselflove.tripod.com/faq45.html
http://malignantselflove.tripod.com/faq57.html
http://open-site.org/Health/Conditions_and_Diseases/Psychiatric_Disorders/Person ality/Antisocial/
Narcissism on Crime TV
http://www.crimelibrary.com/serial_killers/predators/gerald_stano/4.html?sect=2
Crime and Terrorism
http://www.narcissistic-abuse.com/serialkillers.html (PopMatters.com)
http://www.narcissistic-abuse.com/12.html (The Idler)
Corporate Narcissism
http://www.suite101.com/bulletin.cfm/6514/10621 (New York Times)
http://www.narcissistic-abuse.com/corporatenarcissism.html (United Press International - Part I, Part II)
http://www.nypress.com/16/7/news&columns/feature.cfm (New York Press)
Listen to "Psychopaths in Suits" on Australia's ABC Radio
http://www.abc.net.au/rn/talks/bbing/mod/bbing_18072004_2856.ram
Or read the transcript here:
http://www.abc.net.au/rn/talks/bbing/stories/s1158704.htm
Abusive Relationships
http://www.suite101.com/topic_page.cfm/6514/2051
http://www.suite101.com/bulletin.cfm/18046/12847
Mirror, Mirror ... (Toronto Sun)
http://www.canoe.ca/NewsStand/TorontoSun/Lifestyle/2004/08/30/608650.html
Take care.
Sam
> > Hi, > > [quoted text clipped - 43 lines] > > Diana Aaron Morgan - 29 May 2006 09:54 GMT Thanks for the advice, despite the rather ehm.... interesting turn of this thread, diagnosing me as someone with a narcissistic disorder. Oh well..
Anyway, I decided it was time to do something about it, so we've had several deep talks where we've both opened up with our fears and thoughts. That helped. I can see that I do care about her and feel good around her, but perhaps I've had unrealistic expectations to a relationship/finding "the one". It's so easy to compare with those Hollywood movies where everything is perfect, from appearances to full compatibility and no issues.
And in the end it comes down to taking a chance as nothing in life is guaranteed. I have a feeling I should give this a go. It's not that everything is "perfect", but we are good together, and imagining a life with her seems good and safe although scary.
Aaron
shinypenny - 29 May 2006 12:47 GMT > Thanks for the advice, despite the rather ehm.... interesting turn of > this thread, diagnosing me as someone with a narcissistic disorder. Oh [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > everything is "perfect", but we are good together, and imagining a life > with her seems good and safe although scary. No, nothing is guaranteed. The truth is that successful marriages are partly luck, but even more importantly - a huge dose of commitment and determination to make the relationship successful and satisfying! If you both have the will to give it 100%, then you stand a better chance of looking back 20 years from now and laughing at this post you wrote.
:-) May I recommend some reading material?
>From Dr Harriet Lerner: Dance of Intimacy, and the book Fear and Other Uninivited Guests. These two books may help you understand and address your fear of commitment and intimacy, and titrate your anxiety levels as you move forward with your wedding plans.
Check out www.marriagebuilders.com to get an idea what marriage requires to be successful - if you're going to do it, then do it right, and get off on the right foot!
You may also find Dr Phil's relationship books quite helpful. As he says, marriage is both partners giving 100% - not 50/50.
You might also check out the book "Too Good to Leave, Too Bad to Stay." This may help you articulate to yourself why you are making this commitment to this particular woman, beyond the fuzzy "I guess because I love her" stuff, or help you identify any compelling reasons why you shouldn't marry her to begin with.
jen
|
|
|