stealing from Ranger
|
|
Thread rating:  |
beth thomas - 24 Aug 2008 21:55 GMT Ranger posted in another ng about manners and kids...got me to thinking....how much do you stress manners with your kids? Do you expectations have changed since you were a kid? What do you insist on (or not) with your own? Beth
One of the main things I see is a much more casual way of addressing parents...I still can't address my friends' parents (the ones I knew as a kid, that is) by first name, they will always be Mr. or Mrs. Same with aunts and uncles. Now, my kids' friends call me Beth, or Miss Beth , and my niece and nephew don't use 'aunt'. I see my kids' friends being more open / casual with me, not in a rude way, but they will joke and cut up whereas when I was younger I never considered that with the 'rents.
how about you?
Kat - 25 Aug 2008 00:17 GMT > Ranger posted in another ng about manners and kids...got me to > thinking....how much do you stress manners with your kids? Do you [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > > how about you? Well, growing up for me... In the neighbourhood... The neighbours that my parents were friends with and us kids were friends with were known as "Auntie and Uncle" - if they were good friends of my parents. The neighbours that were older and didn't have kids our age were most likely Mr. and Mrs. To this day, that still remains. The next door neighbour that is now probably 80ish is still Mrs. Becker to me - and she keeps insisting we call her, now as adults, Doris. I just can't do it, although it's not that I don't *want* to, really. My parents still call her Mrs. Becker. The neighbours that are my parents' age that have the kids (now adults!) that we grew up with... Still the same... I still call old (then) close childhood friends' parents Auntie Shirley and Uncle Fred, for one example. And the same goes for them - they still refer to my parents as Auntie and Uncle lol I have no friends that my kids call Aunt or Uncle that aren't related - other than 2. My 2 best friends, one dating back to elementary school (who is also DS's godmother) - she is Auntie Leanna, and one from jr. high - she is Auntie Leah. To my friend Leah's DS, I am Auntie as well (and the other friend has no children) We also have a couple good friends - they are known by their first names to my kids, and we go by our first names for their kids. Quite frankly, I do NOT want to be known as "Mrs-Something" to all the kids... That's just maybe a personal thing for me. It actually kind of bothers me to be called a Mrs, Ms or Miss at DS's school lol
...if that rambling makes ANY sense at all...
Ericka Kammerer - 25 Aug 2008 03:15 GMT > Quite frankly, I do > NOT want to be known as "Mrs-Something" to all the kids... That's just maybe > a personal thing for me. I think that's the biggest reason for the drop off in the use of titles by children. It actually worries me a little bit, as there are definitely times when I believe one ought to use more formal address (and one should never presume to use a first name without being invited to do so), and I wonder whether kids will default to informal address when it's inappropriate because they have so little experience with anything else. That's not to say that I think that all kids must call all adults Mr/Ms/Miss/Mrs, but I think it's appropriate when there isn't a reasonably close relationship. My compromise is the old Southern tradition of Miss/Mr FirstName when Title + LastName seems too formal.
Best wishes, Ericka
Kat - 25 Aug 2008 05:08 GMT >> Quite frankly, I do NOT want to be known as "Mrs-Something" to all the >> kids... That's just maybe a personal thing for me. [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > Best wishes, > Ericka I do agree. I almost always address myself by first name. I've actually found that most people we know have done the same. I don't really think I, or we, have any friends that we weren't friends with before the kids were born or shortly after. Almost everyone I still associate with I have known many, many years. If I make an introduction of someone to the kids, I will normally say something like, "DS, this is Mrs. Smith. Billy's mom" - at that point, I do feel it's Mrs. Smith's place to either say nothing and be alright with being known as Mrs. Smith, or it's her choice and place to say, "You know, I am Mrs. Sally Smith, Billy's mom, but you can call me Sally if you'd like." If I'm called a Mrs, I am quick to inform them that the Mrs is my mom, please use my name. I don't even ever recall anyone calling my parents by Mr or Mrs. I've found that this situation is rarely an occurance. Even friends that I don't talk to very much at all or the kids don't know very well, normally I will introduce them under their first name - this is only assuming I *do* know them, and I've found that many, if not almost all, people my age aren't crazy about being a Mr or Mrs ;) Maybe in a few more years that might change, but right now, I do prefer my first name being used, even if the person using my name is a child. I actually think I would be a little shocked and slightly upset if I called a friend's house and their child I know (and knows me) answered and said Mrs is on the phone lol
Ericka Kammerer - 25 Aug 2008 13:37 GMT > If > I'm called a Mrs, I am quick to inform them that the Mrs is my mom, please > use my name. I think it is absolutely your right to be addressed by your first name if that's what you like. The only thing I'd quibble with is telling people, especially kids, "Mrs. is my mom." I think that sends the clear message that titles are only for old, standoffish fuddy duddies. Then, how will the kids feel about the person to whom they're introduced who *doesn't* give them permission to use his or her first name? Also, traditionally, when you give someone permission to address you by your given name, that's a sign of favor and intimacy--something nice. When you handwave it away with the implication that you want to be called by your first name so that you don't feel old, it makes your gesture all about you rather than about a sign of favor for the person you're inviting to use your first name.
Best wishes, Ericka
Banty - 25 Aug 2008 13:05 GMT >> Quite frankly, I do >> NOT want to be known as "Mrs-Something" to all the kids... That's just maybe [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] >is the old Southern tradition of Miss/Mr FirstName when Title + >LastName seems too formal. I agree. And I also agree with the idea that the reason for the drop off is pressure from some parents. The topic would come up, a parent would immediately declare something on the order of "we're not fuddy-duddys here, I want to just be called by my first name". Leaving me to acquiesce or be a fuddy duddy.
Banty
MarieD - 25 Aug 2008 02:38 GMT > One of the main things I see is a much more casual way of addressing > parents...I still can't address my friends' parents (the ones I knew as a [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > open / casual with me, not in a rude way, but they will joke and cut up > whereas when I was younger I never considered that with the 'rents. I can't stand being called "Mrs" anything. A few of the kids' friends call me Miss Marie, and it's all right (and it's easier to pay attention to than when they run up yelling "X's mom, X's mom, X got hurt!" lol I'd rather not be called anything except my name. I don't push the Mr. or Mrs. with my children, either.(or ma'am or sir) Of all the adults I called Mr. or Mrs. when I was little, I still only call one Miss Betty. This same lady who taught me as a child has taught all three of my children so we all call her Miss Betty. No one that I know pronounces the Mrs. properly either, it's always "Miss" or "Mister". We use Aunt and Uncle maybe half the time, but it's not out of respect, it's out of love and it's definately not any kind of proof of having good manners. It also helps prevent confusion if you know more than one person with the same name. Growing up, we called people Mr and Mrs but I remember I called my mom's best friend by her name, without the Mrs, and I also called my best friend's mom by her name.
As for what I consider actual manners- phone manners, table manners, and in public manners, my children and their friends don't have problems with any of these, but I have had problems with a couple of family members. One had a tantrum in the store at age 10 and was pouty and petty the whole weekend she stayed here. And as much as she wants to come back, I will not allow a child(that old!) who behaves that way to stay with me. And I have neices who refuse to eat just about anything and will only eat fried cheese sticks, chicken nuggets, corn dogs and cheese pizza. They will not even taste a new food. My childrens' friends who stay at my house will eat anything and will try anything new. Marie
MarieD - 25 Aug 2008 02:46 GMT > I see my kids' friends being more open / casual with me, not in a rude > way, but they will joke and cut up whereas when I was younger I never > considered that with the 'rents. I didn't comment on this part earlier. There were certain parents who were more open to communication with their kids' friends, and I think those are more likely to be joked around with. I have a group of friends and all of our daughters are good friends and house-hop frequently, and they all are also close to all the moms. It feels really great, and all the moms have talked about it and appreciate the openness. My mom's best friend growing up was always-to me-very strange. Her family was so quiet, and at dinner time no one talked, smiles at their house were very rare. So I wouldn't have dared joked or even talked unless I was asked a question. Their daughter and I were friends until we grew up and parted ways. But then my best friend's family was very open and funny and talkative and I wouldn't have dared NOT joked or talked at her house. Thankfully we are still close friends after all this time. Do you think maybe they are more casual with you because you allow them to be, and you don't make them feel awkward? I just hope that having friends like that means if there is trouble they will feel they can talk to you about it. My oldest is only 13 and there's been no real trouble yet so I guess we'll see! Marie
Teri - 28 Aug 2008 19:23 GMT > Ranger posted in another ng about manners and kids...got me to > thinking....how much do you stress manners with your kids? Do you [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > > how about you? I insist (should say when they were very young I used to insist, now they just do) that when people come to visit my children come up and greet them and when it's time to leave, the children come to say good bye. I'm often at other people's homes where the children offer a cursory wave without their eyes leaving the tv. My kids ask if anyone else wants the last piece of whatever, before taking it. During holiday or extended family dinners, the kdis ask if they can be excused from the table. Teri
Sue from NZ - 08 Sep 2008 21:55 GMT > Ranger posted in another ng about manners and kids...got me to > thinking....how much do you stress manners with your kids? Do you [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > > how about you? We're strict on manners
Actually we *were* strict - no need to be now as everywhere we take Tyler we have people commenting on his beautiful manners.
I don't like the kids being on equal footing with adults as much as they are today - call me a prude but there ya go. Kids today (at least here in New Zealand) are taught of all their rights, that they are equal to adults etc, but they're not taught any responsibilities....
We always introduce people to Tyler as "Mr, Mrs, Ms, Miss" etc, then it's up to them to say if they want him to call them by their first name.
Sue from NZ
:)
|
|
|